Thursday, August 12, 2010

Quick Comparison: RequisitePro, DOORs, and Requirements Composer

Ever since the acquisition of Telelogic by IBM, it has been quite a challenge to figure out what tool fits best and in what context.

Here is a quick compilation:

General/historic tool use

DOORS

 

 

RequisitePro

Systems

 

 

Software/IT

Formal Req. Change Process

Lightweight Req. Change Management

Telelogic Tools / Harmony Process

Rational Tools / RUP

Reviewer Web Client

 

Full Web Client

Formal Rigorous Compliance / FDA

IT Compliance

More expensive

 

Less expensive

(adopted from this presentation)

The Requirements Composer complements both DOORs and ReqPro by providing capturing, modeling, diagramming, and collaboration capabilities.

Capability

ReqPro

DOORS

Requirements Composer

Word integration

great

poor

none

Manage requirements

great

great

poor

Req. Lifecycle Traceability

great

great

poor

Web-based access

great

poor

good

Detailed reporting for standards compliance

good

great

poor

Tool integration

good

good

good

Rich text capture

none

good

great

UI sketches and storyboards

none

none

great

Diagramming

none

none

great

Dashboards

none

none

good

The roadmap at IBM is to merge DOORs and ReqPro in the new product out in 2011: http://jazz.net/projects/rational-requirements-composer/

This is a larger ALM vision IBM has for their products: http://jazz.net/projects/rational-workbench-for-clm/

 

No comments:

Post a Comment